A family was lucky not to have suffered more serious injuries when the balcony they were eating dinner on gave way and they plunged up to six metres onto concrete on Sydney’s lower north shore, their rescuers say.
One woman is expected to undergo surgery at the Royal North Shore Hospital on Thursday for extensive fractures but nine others have since been released from hospital after the balcony at a duplex in Lane Cove collapsed about 10.15pm on Wednesday.

Inspector Jeff Bell, the duty officer from the North Shore local area command, said a couple had gathered their extended family members for a dinner at the Lane Cove property on Wednesday night when the accident occurred.

The group of 12 people had just finished eating dinner and had stood up to head back inside when the timber balcony, measuring about six metres by four metres, suddenly gave way.

The 12 people and the furniture, including table and chairs, slid off the balcony, which was left hanging from the side of the duplex. One edge of the balcony came to rest on a car parked below.


“They got up to go inside and the part of the balcony that connects to the house basically disconnected from the house and then went fairly vertically. They all just slid off it, so to speak,” Inspector Bell said.

“The first floor had about a one-metre wide patio on it. Some of them fell onto that, which stopped the fall, and half of them fell just straight down into the garage section, another three metres further.”

He estimated five of the group fell the full six metres into the garage section.

“Considering the distance they fell and the potential for injury – falling onto a hard surface, and various bits of furniture fell with them, table and chairs and all the rest of it – it was quite amazing the injuries weren’t worse,” he said.

Six ambulances and a rescue helicopter were called to the duplex on the Pacific Highway, and paramedics joined police and Fire and Rescue NSW officers in a delicate 70-minute operation to rescue the casualties and secure the scene.

“Some of them had to be stabilised with neck braces because of the potential for spinal injury,” Inspector Bell said.

“The ones that were on the first floor level on the patio, it was quite a narrow stairway and they had to lift them over their heads. As far as things go, the rescue went surprisingly smoothly,” he said.

Ten people were taken to Royal North Shore Hospital, he said. Eight were taken by ambulance to hospital with a range of spinal, pelvic and limb injuries, while two others later took themselves to the hospital for treatment.

Inspector Bell said nine had since been released, but a 31-year-old woman remained in the intensive care unit and was expected to undergo surgery on Thursday for extensive fractures.

Neighbours reported hearing a large crash from 300 metres away when the balcony collapsed.

Inspector Bell said the duplex was an older, brick building that appeared to have been renovated. The deck was added eight years ago, he said.

“It’s an eight-year-old deck which had stood the test of time, until now. What caused this will have to be investigated,” he said.

Engineers are expected to begin examining the site on Thursday morning.

Lane Cove mayor Scott Bennison said the current system of having private inspectors certify buildings was not working and needed to change.

He said the Building Professionals Board and state government bodies had contacted the council on Thursday, and the certification of the balcony, which was built in 2006, would be investigated.

”From our perspective, this is one of the problems that we have with certifiers, that when something goes wrong, we’re not a part of the process,” Cr Bennison said.

”We didn’t participate or have control in that process and we have no feedback as to what should be done to prevent it from happening again.”

He called for councils to be given the role of overseeing private certifiers, with the ability to issue fines ”to keep them honest, so to speak”.

”When things go wrong, they go wrong badly,” he said. ”Fortunately there has been no loss of life in this instance.”

Addbuild Masterbuilders, which completed the deck in 2005, had not yet been in contact with any authorities, but had spoken to the owner, its general manager, Cheryl Paton, said.

“And at this stage we haven’t inspected the deck and until we carry out an inspection and have a chance to talk to engineers and other authorities I can’t really make any further comment,’’ she said.

The Planning Minister, Brad Hazzard, said the government was concerned about the incident, but cautioned against pre-empting the findings of the investigation.

“It could be related to anything from initial design through to construction and material quality,” he said.

“If there are issues relating to the certifier then that will be closely scrutinised as the government is already moving to improve the framework around the oversight of private certifiers.”

This story was found at: http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/lucky-escape-10-hurt-in-balcony-collapse-at-family-dinner-20130228-2f70j.html


Megan Levy

Published: February 28, 2013 – 9:32PM

You must be logged in to post a comment.